Yvette Carnell: Black Man Tells Gingrich to ‘Stop Using Blacks as Punching Bag’

by Yvette Carnell

Last week, Newt Gingrich intimated that he would happily accept an invitation to the NAACP since it would provide him an opportunity to tell the black community why they should demand paychecks instead of food stamps. This week, Gingrich is still defending those rancid comments.

At a town hall in Manchester New Hampshire, Gingrich was taken to task by Yvan Lamothe, a black man and small business owner, who challenged Gingrich on his comment. Lamothe said that he’s never been on food stamps and was offended by Gingrich’s insinuation that all black people are either on or have been on welfare. Following is the transcript of the exchange:

LAMOTHE: My question to you is, do think blacks represent an American problem. And if you don’t think that, when you start using blacks in general as a stepping stone or a punching bag–

GINGRICH: I didn’t say that. I just want to say that frankly this makes me very irritated. The Democratic National Committee took totally out of context half of the sentence, OK? I mean clearly somebody who’s served with Colin Powell, who has served with Condoleezza Rice, I have a fairly good sense of the fact that African Americans have many contributions to America.

If Gingrich has a good sense that black people are actually contributors, as opposed to takers, then it makes no sense that he would paint all black folks with one broad brush, unless of course,  he’s race baiting to gain some momentum for his floundering campaign, in which case, that makes it all the worse.

Truth be told, there has always been a core constituency of right wingers, or should I say dead-enders, who view black people as an American problem. And that’s the choir to which Gingrich was singing with his ‘food stamp’ comment. He should be ashamed, but given his past, we all know that shame is not an emotion with which Gingrich is familiar.

Yvette Carnell is a former Capitol Hill and campaign staffer turned writer. She is currently an editor and contributor for Yourblackworld. 

Enhanced by Zemanta

More From Your Black World:



0saves
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.
  • jannay

    Newt and the others are playing to the crowd that says they want to take their country back.  Which is from Black people.  They believe that white people are giving Black people their monies and that Black people don’t pay taxes.  I have never been on food stamps my entire life.  Have worked for over 30 years.  Paid taxes like every other American citizens.  This is an insult to all Black people.

    • LFSOUTHPHI

      Jwoods1044 I am with you !  I am a single African american woman, with one child and I too have never been on  welfare or food stamps.  I am 59 years old, and have been working since the age of 16.  I too pay taxes like other Americans, and I am very insulted by Mr Gingrich’s statement. 

    • For Real

      I am a mirror image of how you just described yourself

  • http://jannay.wordpress.com/ Jwoods1044

    Newt response is like saying, “I have a black friend”.

    • Mz

      That is funny because that’s what I thought as I read the comment. “Some of my closest friends are black.’ I always hear that when I challenge an of color comment by any other race. The truth of the matter is that it doesn’t matter if you have or have never recieved welfare, limiting it to one racial group is just wrong-period. We don’t have to weigh each individual that has or has not. I have and many of my friends and family members have also-that’s what its for! At the same time I have an array of family and friends that has no experience with welfare-so what! Everyone needs a little help some time. We are no less valuable than any person who doesnt have the experience. We still pay taxes and have paid generously into this system and there is no shame if we turn to temporary assistance at some point. Many Hispanics and an overflow of white people pollute the welfare programs and other subsidies. They live everywhere from downtown Chicago to the waterfront of Seattle- where the woman was collecting while live in a million dollar property. Congress and the House is filled with Old Timers with old ideas. Basically all of them are out of touch with the real society.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYYDHJY6RDHGAGY7MQCDLVRSTE Craig

    Newt is nuts man last 20 yrs 

  • AngrymanT

    phuck Newt and Santorum!  I get tired of these people sayin’ shyt then talk about someone took it out of context!  NO THE HELL THEY DIDN’T!  And I’m tired of these white folks trying to scapegoat black folks!!

  • David2001

    The white news media is doing a poor job confronting these republicans on this type of racist propaganda. What this black man did is an example of what we as black people are going to have to do. Start showing up at these republicans rallies/town hall meetings and confront them on their racism. Event though we aren’t voting for them we need to hold them accountable for this racist crap.

  • Eric Lett

    You took the words righ out of my mouth Jannay with your comment “I have a black friend”

  • Aavix

    The fact that he speaks that way about blacks shows that he is not only a racist, but so out of touch look around most Americans are out of work and have lost their homes.  He needs to explain how he will help the situation not try to sit there and slander a whole race of people.  It’s just seems like it is so much easier to tear people down rather than find a solution.  He should be ashamed of himself!

  • Ciara7ca

    Yes, this is a blatant insult. There are more white people on food stamps in this country than there are blacks.

  • Play Righter

    Can anybody give any evidence to the charges here?  He was asked about addressing the NAACP — which means the topic would necessarily be black people.  I don’t believe he ever said anything about “all blacks”, but am open to any evidence to the contrary.  Saying that blacks should demand paychecks over food stamps sounds like empowerment to me. How about you?

    • David2001

      EVERYONE on food stamps WHITE, BLACK, HISPANIC, ASIAN, ETC should demand a paycheck over food stamps idiot. That’s the point. Why single out black people??? You sound like a typical right wing teabag idiot to me. Newt has been given the opportunity to speak to the NAACP FOUR TIMES according to current head Ben Jealous but turned them down FOUR TIMES!! “Jealous said Gingrich had been invited to speak to his group several
      times when he served as speaker, but declined the invitations”  Newt Gingrich like other republican candidates don’t give a damn about black people. This was about appealing to white racist idiots who like to think of ALL blacks as welfare recipients. The vast majority of people on food stamps are WHITE. Why go to the white state of Iowa and talk about black people and food stamps when the majority in that state are white?? ?? To pander to dumb white racist teabag republicans.

      • Play Righter

        I’ll ignore your charge of “idiot”, as you have no basis for it.  (Also, I’m a lifelong independent, so your other assumption is also wrong).

        Whites do collect more in food stamps.  That’s not the point.  Gingrich was asked about addressing the NAACP.  Therefore the topic was black people.  (Had he been asked about addressing the NAAWP, you might have a valid point).

        Again, I ask for evidence to the charges, rather than personal attacks.

        And thank you for agreeing that everyone on food stamps should demand a paycheck over food stamps, thus proving the point that Newt saying so was not racist.

        • You Big Dummy

          anyone defending a racist like newt must be a racist.  in your attempt to get everyone to focus on the naacp, you conveniently forget he has a long history of racist remarks towards black people that are indefensible. 

          • Play Righter

            I would never defend racism.  The topic here was his comments regarding the NAACP, in response (as I’ve read) to a question he was asked.  I asked for evidence of racism in this case.  If you want to spread the field, we can ask how racist “Take back our country” is –when it was used by Saul Alinsky in 1972, and Barack Obama in 2006.

          • You Big Dummy

            no i do not wish to spread the field are waste my time with a racist like you. 

            if you’re going to be a racist…do be a closet racist…david duke and others like newt have opened the doors for racist like you to come out. 

    • Fool

      sounds like you’re a fool…that is what it sounds like to me. 

    • DAMAGED

      Who the phuck is he to empower anybody. Newt ain’t shit but a filthy ass racist that was raised by a preg teen mom. Mr MORALS! pHUCK YOU AND nEWT.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Spencer-Leon-Miller/100000043702090 Spencer Leon Miller

    I really have a difficult time trying to understand the GOP’s obsession with denigrating blacks lately.  I could only assume that these people are seeking the so-called tea party vote. What they don’t realize is this could hurt them rather than help them and Gingrich really needs all the help he can get.

  • Darscb6

    The news media should not have to take Newt to task it should be all those Black Republicans, JC Watts, Michael Steele, Herman Cain and the few Black Republican females that sit on MSNBC, CNN and Fox and spout the racist rhetoric right along with him that should stand up and say “wait a minute, I work along side you and have never been on food stamps a day in my life, so you can’t lump us all in one bucket” but then he wouldn’t want to be friends with them because they’d be standing up for Black folks instead of talking against them which is why they are accepted by the Republican party.  It’s the old song of “divide and conquer”.  They’re just too stupid to see it.

    • JanetL

      Micheal Steel Stood Up on Rev. Al’s show, imagine our surprise.  Mr. Steel told the Republican Party to “STOP IT”  It’s not true and they know it’s not true and went on to say the Black Community is like other with Billionaires, Millionaires, scholars, college degrees, harding working folk who work every day just like any other ethnic group.

      Thank you Micheal Steel

      JC Watts was given an opportunity to call these liars out he passed and kept supporting them, shameful

  • Samuel McElrath

    PEOPLE,   A leopard does not change his spots!!!

  • Burleycynthia45

    What planet is this %^^$#@ wanna be from? He talks about black people being on welfare and food stamps, has he checked the poverty level statistics lately, there’s more white people on welfare and  food stamps than blacks, (some upper class that haven’t gotten caught yet).  Somebody need’s to shut this man up and put this ass hole in his place. 

  • powell1960

    Mr. Newt Gingrich is so wrong. Most people in this country are white. Most of the people that get food stamps in this country are white.

  • Tom

    The man is a flame throwing fat slob!  He makes a terrible appearance & he has an ugly wife. Can you even imagine this man becoming president & having to watch him and that woman on TV almost everyday.  God help us everyone!  And when I say that I’m including well thinking Whites who fear him just as much.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Olin-Ross/546574576 Olin Ross

    I don’t see his remarks as offensive…..Why???Because it came from the mouth of a sleazebag or scumbag…This is just like a crazy person coming up to me and calling me a racist…..This guy has zero credibility……..Most Immoral person who ever ran for president….

  • Procelain

     Gingrich, I hope you know this goes both ways, I know you are probably trying to line up this service for white people, if this does happen we want have mother killing themselves and they’re babies in the Public Aid office because the people working there did not want to assist her and she was white.  

  • chanelit

    Newt’s brain is the size of a newt.This racist, idiot, bastard is so patriotic that his penis…which is probably the size of a newt, stands at attention everytime he feels passionate and patriotic about his country. Rick Santorum’s ignorant, holier than thou, christian conservative, family values ass thinks the same way.

    However, he represented some of the poorest appalachian Pennsylvanians in the senate. Lets not forget that this holy man also hung out with the crooks on K Street right along side  with freaky ass Tom Delay, Casino Jack Abramoff and adulterer John Esign.

     Rick! I wonder how these dirt broke penniless poor appalachians white pennsylvanians buy there meth?  With food stamps?  Ooops! Was that a stereotype? Awwwwl, I’m sorry, I thought all poor white folk from Pen
    The man is crazy. He is tried to say last week he is an adulterer because he is so patriotic his penis stands at attention & he must use i
    nsyvania purchase meth with foodstamps. You hear how phucking ignorant that sounds. The both of you are christian assholes.        

  • Jaleelshkr

    This is just old newt trying to garner votes from the uninformed to the racist.
    Just say anything bad or negative about african american people and watch the main
    stream media ignore it, like it was never said.

  • JanetL

    The man who asked the question was on MSNBC last night.

    He told us how he was young married, wife expecting he lost his job, had to ask the Salvation Army for help but never took welfare

    This same man told us how he with the grace of God put himself throught college has a Masters Degree and his 4-Kids all have college degrees.

    He said he was tired of all this sterotyping of his community and he knew that more Whites were on Welfare than Blacks and felt it was time to start confronting these folks who say such lies about the Black Community

    Love the interview, absolutely awesome and you should follow up with his story

    Santorum was confronted by a Black Mother asking the same question.

    It’s time to confront these liars, because they have gotton too comfortably telling the same lies over and over and finally the Media is giving the Facts the Actual Statistics showing that Whites are the Majority on Welfare and FoodStamps

    It’s nothing to be ashamed of and we should help those in need as Scripture teaches

    It’s those who are looking to Use Blacks to promote Racism in our country knowing they are Lying

    Newt Gingrigh is a Professor of History so he knows the Truth and should be continually called out everytime he tells this lie

    Newt Gingrign knows he’s lying and is attempting to get the White votes of those who are racist to win the Nomination. 

  • ana

    Why are African Americans are always portrayed as welfare recipients? The truth of the matter is,The United States is begining to become a Welfare Country.The Citizens of The United States of America,has been Misused and Abused by Wall Street,The Entire Banking Industry,The Corporate Crooks and The Entire Lending Industry! The United States Citizens gave them A Big Bail-Out!  Will The Real Welfare Recipients Please Stand Up!!!    Ask China Exactly What Do They Think Of North America!!!