Kirsten West Savali: The Reason For The Season — And It’s Not Jesus

Winter Solstice

By: Kirsten West Savali, Your Black World

Growing up in an African Methodist Episcopal household as a child (A.M.E. — shout out to Richard Allen!), the annual Christmas program was a huge deal. From the flowing red gowns of the female choir members to the gold candles illuminating the sanctuary in a warm glow, the soaring notes of “O Holy Night,” and “Silent Night’ were congregant favorites. Everyone would sway and sing along, celebrating the birth of their one, true savior, Jesus — or Joshua for those people who like to be historically correct.

There’s only one small problem:

December 25 is not his birthday.

Biblical scholars have debunked the blind belief that Jesus was born on December 25 time and time again—instead, through scientific, historical and astrological calculations, pinpointing September of the year 3 B.C. as a more accurate date—, but for some reason, as is the case with Easter, creationism, and the entire Old Testament, many Christians have wrestled the concept from its origins, even going so far as declaring that people are heathens, ungrateful and unscrupulous for daring to take the “Christ” out of X-mas.

I guess I would feel more comfortable with the scathing criticism, if in fact, Christmas was ever intended to be a Christian holiday, but it was not. That is not myth, legend or subjective opinion, that is fact.

Many people are familiar with the Winter Solstice, and for those who are not, it’s when the sun reaches it’s lowest point in the sky on December 21, actually appearing to stop moving for three days, then rising again on December 25.  With just a cursory examination, one can understand that the “Birth of the Son” is actually the “Return of the Sun.”  And those three wise men? The three stars of Orion’s Belt have always been referred to as “The Three Kings,” and astronomy tells us that they appear to follow the bright star, Sirius, who over the years has evolved into Mary, the Virgin Mother.

Besides the fact that the day in question is relevant to a long list of deities throughout antiquity who pre-date Jesus, from Persia’s pagan Sun God Mithra to Egypt’s Horus and Ra, to Syria’s Baal, Rome’s Sol Invictus and Greece’s Helios, it wasn’t until the year 350 A.D., that Pope Julius I declared that the “Christ-Mass” would be held on December 25, to celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ.

There are many Christians who frown upon this conversation, and that’s fine; but, I think the fact that December 25 is no more the birth of Jesus Christ, than an obese white man from the North Pole sliding down the chimney—the last I heard, that’s called breaking and entering—to give children presents should be examined.  The culmination of the Winter Solstice, when farmers rejoiced in the re-appearance of the sun, when the darkness lifted and warmth began to fill people’s lives again is just as worthy of celebration as a supermarket Santa or the fictitious birthday of Jesus — even more so in my opinion, because it’s real.

We all need the sun, we all depend on it to live healthy lives, it is the solar force that enables plants to bloom and trees to grow. And while I don’t believe that it should be worshiped, I see absolutely nothing wrong with acknowledging it’s power and being grateful for its presence without being bombarded with questions regarding faith—as many of us agnostics are—, or being judged for not accepting the myth that has taken on a life of its own.

Can the church say, ‘A-men’?

Whether strong faith, or none, those who are so blessed, should all be grateful for our families, friends and good health; we should continue to reach out into our communities and care for those who may be lacking all three and most of all, we should not let something so simple as one day cause unnecessary divisiveness when it should be a time of joy for all.

So Happy Winter Solstice everyone — may your days be filled with the warmth, peace and growth of a million suns!

And for those who just can’t force themselves to re-think the real reason for the season — Merry Christmas. We’ll save the discussion on the holiday’s franchise player, Santa Claus— and his impersonation of Babylon’s Nimrod—for next year.

 

 

More From Your Black World:



0saves
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.
  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Justin-Phoenix/100003106767924 Justin Phoenix

    That is why we celebrate Kwaaza and Santa Claws.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Justin-Phoenix/100003106767924 Justin Phoenix

    That is why we celebrate Kwaaza and Santa Claws.

  • Anonymous

    Kirsten,

    I am fascinated by your piece. I am PhD student in Christian origins at a secular University, and despite examining the context of the infancy stories and their parallels for over a year I never found the examples you just gave. I noticed you didn’t provide any references to these points of the parallels, either to the primary material or to where you got these ideas from that you have just presented to your readers. I checked the standard texts on the infancy stories, including Vermes “Nativity: History and Legend”, and Corley’s “New Perspectives on the Nativity”, as well as Brown’s “Birth of the Messiah” and such references are also missing. It would be fascinating if you could disclose where you pulled your article from for, at present, it seems to be missing from every scholarly discussion on the infancy story. 

    • Ann

      Hanery, I’m not a PhD and I have heard all of the stories/theories mentioned above. The truth is out there….

      • Anonymous

        Ann.

        Yes but where? Are these from conspiracy theory website by hack amateurs who just claim this. Is there actually any evidence at all for it, where are the sources for these claims that no scholar seems to know anything about? I mean there are a lot of creationist, global warming, 9/11 was done by the government etc… websites. Its surely not wrong to ask for evidence for these claims, to ask where and who you get information from. But I will wait and I can look up the evidence once someone, somewhere, provides us for the first time with references for these claims. I suppose Kirsten as a profession journalist will have these and will pass these on. She will also have the distinction of changing an entire scholarly field with these dramatic and new revelations that no scholar of the field has yet discovered.

        • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mamas-Matriarch/100001522987065 Mamas Matriarch

          HOW ABOUT YOU LOOK IT UP. Your kind trips me out. Just like you want to keep the Jesus myth going when there is no evidence of his actual birth day either, proves you dont really WANT TO KNOW. INFORMATION is INFORMATION. Trying to kill the messenger just proves your lack of logical reasoning.

          • Anonymous

            I would love to look it up, if someone would tell me where on all earth one may find it, because no source material seems to exist for it, no historian knows of it. So where on all earth I am to look?

            I don’t know what “kind” you think I am. I have little interest in keeping “the Jesus myth going”, in fact if you read the books I referenced above you will see exactly how the infancy stories were created to fit preconceived ideas. I have an interest in historical research- in fact I am paid to do work on the history of early Christianity. “information is information” uh huh, and I want to know where this information, that no scholar knows of, comes from. I find it, well disconcerting that you think someone asking for evidence and questioning statements is somehow who is showing a lack of logical reasoning. Its the exact opposite. If you want to keep believing what Kirsten said fine, but don’t pretend, unless you have tried to ascertain the accuracy of it, that you have any reason another than your own desire for it to be true.

    • Mika

      Thanks Kristen! I am graduate student in theology and I must say that there isn’t any credible research to support these claims. Anthony Mcroy (lecturer in Islamic Studies at the Wales Evangelical School of Theology) does a wonderful job debunking such popular myths about the supposed pagan roots of Christmas and Easter. He began researching this topic when he kept hearing these charges of syncretism leveled against him during encounters with certain Muslims. Apparently, much of the steam behind these terrible rumors came from a popular internet film called the Zeitgest which serious historical scholars dismiss. You can’t believe everything that you see in a movie or read on the internet, especially when its not checked by credible academic sources. For instance, Richard Gordon, editor of the journal of Mithraic studies, contends that very little is known about the Roman cult of Mithras since historians are mostly working with iconography and brief inscriptions from second-hand sources. In fact, historians don’t know Mithras’ supposed birthdate or whether the cult even had a liturgical year at all. Another Mithraic scholar, Manfred Claus (author of “The Roman Cult of Mithras” and professor at the Free university of Berlin) also vigorously denies that Mithraism had any influence on Christianity at all. The supposed parrallels between the Feast of the Nativity (Christmas) and any pagan celebrations are quite simply fallacious. Christians can celebrate Christmas with a clear conscience!   

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mamas-Matriarch/100001522987065 Mamas Matriarch

        An Islamic MALE wants to debunk pagan myths when ISLAM ROOTS ARE PAGAN ALSO…LOL! You all are delusion. Your Education means nothing. Everything Kristen said is CORRECT and no matter how you want to deny it, the similarities are not a coincidence. This information can be found doing a random google search or even watching OTHER EDUCATED SCHOLARS debunk Christianity on the History Channel. My gosh what people do to follow sweet baby jesus.

  • Anonymous

    In 2010 Bo Sr. died, the last speaker and conservator of a language some 65,000 years old. The debate over which myth should be believed is interesting in that the Bo surely must have had some myths in their 65,000 year journey. I spend no time on the myths of others. If you do not believe that the Bo existed before the records of evidence of Southern Europe and Northern Africa I can not help you. As best I can tell myths allow individuals to organize their experiences, somehow making sense of what they have before them.

    In my world, I agree that the ‘sun,’ whatever that means, comes up in the ‘east,’ whatever that means. Proofs do not come easily. In fact, in my world they do not come at all. I offer one note, if the sun comes up in the west ‘tomorrow,’ whatever that means, I am running for the hills and I hope you follow me. You, then, can practice the religion of ME.

  • Anonymous

    In 2010 Bo Sr. died, the last speaker and conservator of a language some 65,000 years old. The debate over which myth should be believed is interesting in that the Bo surely must have had some myths in their 65,000 year journey. I spend no time on the myths of others. If you do not believe that the Bo existed before the records of evidence of Southern Europe and Northern Africa I can not help you. As best I can tell myths allow individuals to organize their experiences, somehow making sense of what they have before them.

    In my world, I agree that the ‘sun,’ whatever that means, comes up in the ‘east,’ whatever that means. Proofs do not come easily. In fact, in my world they do not come at all. I offer one note, if the sun comes up in the west ‘tomorrow,’ whatever that means, I am running for the hills and I hope you follow me. You, then, can practice the religion of ME.

  • Anonymous

    I had intended to comment on this post but I decided that it would be a waste of time. The writer has truths, half truths, and an obvious bias against Christianity. As the saying goes, “none is as blind as those who will not see.”

  • LeL

    Black people always need a white person to cosign for there beliefs, my people this is the internet, it’s full of information, so make a informed decision of you own and research the topic at hand to walk into your own degree of knowledge.  Overall this is a great article and anyone whom has already studied the topic would be able to point to their own sources of information, especially students in a university.

  • Anonymous

    I thought Constantine,hope I’m spelling it right had more influence on the establishment of the Christian faith than anyone,as far as the rules,Dec 25th was suppose to be Mithra’s birthday,and he was trying to accept all of it,not give up anything,the devil is in the details we know this,but I still celebrate because as they say, God turned it around and mean’t it for good,it doesn’t matter when he was born,only that I recongnize it,and I am  a history buff,love a good  arguement,it early people for me,I’m still half asleep,Merry Christmas and God bless

  • Berdell

    Since the exact day is not known the 25th is the day that has been chosen to celebrate his birth. Merry Christmas all!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EGXZ26MK42CPGJ2FMIR3VXS4T4 flextime

    The first thing people shouldknow about religion is that faith comes from within.  You don’t need a prophet or fictional characters in a book to make things happen.  Hard Work, education and proper decisions will bring a person farther.