Facts You May Not Know About the Troy Davis Case

Help stop the execution of Troy Davis

by Dr. Boyce Watkins, Your Black World

Rev. Jesse Jackson and I, along with the Your Black World Coalition, are petitioning for clemency in the death sentence of Troy Davis.  We are reaching out to Georgia Governor Nathan Deal, the Georgia State Board of Pardons and Paroles and US President Barack Obama in our request that Davis’ case be reconsidered in light of overwhelming evidence that shows that he was not proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

Troy Davis has been on death row in the state of Georgia since 1991.  He was convicted on August 19, 1989 of the murder of Georgia police officer, Mark MacPhail.  On August 24, 2010, the conviction was upheld, with the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Georgia declaring, “Davis is not innocent.”  The judge did not say that Davis is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, implying that the standard for exoneration had been lifted unreasonably high.

Here are some other facts about the Davis case that lead us at the Your Black World Coalition to believe that justice has not been served.  We are neutral regarding the guilt or innocence of Davis, but instead believe that all exculpatory evidence should be examined to determine if there is reasonable doubt as to whether or not Davis committed this crime.  As we appeal to YBW Coalition members to sign our petition to free Davis, these are some facts that we’ve considered:

 

1)      Of the nine original witnesses in the case, seven have either recanted or contradicted their original stories

2)      Of the two witnesses who have not recanted, one of them was a suspect in the murder, Sylvester Coles.  A witness even claimed that Coles bragged at a party about having killed an off-duty police officer.

3)      Nine individuals have signed affidavits indicting that the murder was committed by Sylvester Coles

4)      Troy’s date of execution has been set for September 21, 2011 – so we must move quickly.

5)      The Georgia State Board of Pardons and Paroles has originally stated that the execution would only take place if there is “no doubt” about the guilt of the man they are killing.  We argue that there is tremendous doubt in the case of Troy Davis.

Please take action to help us save Troy’s life by signing our petition.  All submitted letters will go to Georgia Governor Nathan Deal, the Georgia State Board of Pardons and Paroles, as well as President Barack Obama.

 

 

More From Your Black World:



0saves
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.
  • Anonymous

    Can you tell us why are you appealing to this President of the U.S., to free this man, even though you are not sure of his innocence, or guilt? Have you, and Jesse Jackson ever made similar appeals to former presidents? In your own words, you state that there is a possibility that he committed this murder, only there is a reasonable doubt. This case belongs in the courts, and should not be litigated, nor prosecuted by special interest groups. The President, would be crazy, to get involved in this case, at this time.

    • Brook

      It’s not about whether he is guilty or innocent.  It’s about the fact that a person must be found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.  It was not proven that he was guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, since a whole bunch of witnesses have changed their story.  Would you bet a million dollars that he’s guilty for sure?  I don’t think so. 

      • LeCalabro

        He was found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt–its just that many people don’t want to accept that fact.

        • PETTYB

          Or is it that you don’t want to accept the fact that the man could be innocent? What if something like this was to happen to your son, father,brother,uncle,grandfather and nobody steped in to declaire their innocents how would you feel? Huh how would you feel? Some of yall are as cold hearted as the days are long you might need to sit back one day and take a look at yourself one day!

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Iris-Boyd/611306703 Iris Boyd

      In desperation, people are now asking the President to do something but given that this is a State Case and not a Federal Case, there is nothing that the President can do in this matter.  If he did, he will be overreaching his authority and that would be a big mistake.

      I’m sure that West and Smiley who has been awol in this case will find a way hold President Obama responsible.

      • Anonymous

        Yes, you are correct, West, Smiley, and this Dr. Boyce believe that Obama was elected to be their personal servant. The president’s job is to govern over the entire country, and it’s interests. He has no time or authority, to get involved in every states matters. Do you know how many people that are innocent, or claim to be innocent there are in prisons in this country? If the president, would get involved in just a small fraction of these cases, he would not have any time to govern this country. The three idiots, that are mentioned above, and other stupid fools, are probably going to blame Obama, but these same idiots, never put the blame on any of the prior presidents, when other self proclaimed innocent people were executed.

        I myself believe that Troy Davis may be innocent, and deserves at least the chance to prove once again that he is innocent, but I definitely don’t believe that the President of the United States, should get involved in anything that isn’t of national importance. To answer some of the idiots, that are going to say that every president, pardons people at times, the answer is yes they do, but usually at the end of their terms, and normally not for crimes that involve death, and certainly not the death of an police officer.

  • Marjani

    The CBC should have been on top of this a long time ago.

    Troy is not guilty. I read over the entire case in the circuit court of appeals in Georgia more than two years ago.

    1) There is no murder weapon. It disappeared and was never recovered. 
    2) There is no weapon, no DNA evidence, no witnesses to the officer’s murder…nothing except nine witnesses of whom 7 say they were coerced by police.
    3) Two of the remaining ones was the one they saw with the gun in his hands moments before Officer MacPhail was shot.

    Troy was convicted on nothing but the testimony of nine “witnesses” who (a) admitted they didn’t really see anything on Day 1; and (b) who now not only say they didn’t see anything, but the police forced them to testify against him even though they were well aware that all of the witnesses stated they never saw the officer get shot.

    The guy everyone saw with the gun in his hand (though no one saw who actually shot the officer) was one of the “witnesses who didn’t see anything” who testified against Troy.

    The CBC absolutely needs to take this case to the President and have a FEDERAL attorney investigate it. The man at least deserves a fair trial and a look at the mitigating evidence before they take his life and then go “ooopss” after it’s too late.

    • LeCalabro

      A lot of people investigated this case in the past 19 years. Troy Davis is guilty of murdering that police officer and “jury nullification” and blacks changing their original testimony will not make him innocent of murder.  Blacks need to support Justice, even when a black is the perpetrator.

      • Jackbenumber

        only white folks  get off the hook for  everything a white man killed the police officer and a black man died for it  that is nothing new but if i was the davis family i would sue all of you white mother fuckers.

  • Smel87

    If he did it, let him hang , as the law dictates. If there is reasonable doubt, again as the law dictates, then let his life be spared.

    • WhoseJustice

      Reasonable doubt to me is the fact that police detectives in 1989 felt the need to force a witness who was with Troy Davis to LIE and say that he saw Troy Davis shoot at a car earlier that evening, and that witness refused to lie during the trial, where he testified that he was threatened with 10-12 years as an accessory if he didn’t lie on his police statement. 

      • LeCalabro

        Where is to proof to that assertion, that the police forced a witness to LIE?

  • Ron

    This man is not the killer. 

  • Ron

    THE bottom line is that they have not founded the real killer and just wants to kill someone illeagally.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_J3MYHXL3XUKQMP6EEAJ2F6DZBM leah

    I pray that God steps in … it seems as if there is nothing left to do. The days are upon us and this man needs a miracle!

    • LeCalabro

      Justice needs a miracle—-Troy Davis is guilty of murdering that police officer. That is the truth. 

  • usman

    Blackmen will continue to fall into dangerous no win legal situation like this unless we just make a conscious effort to avoid situations that may sweep us into trouble and by extension into prison. The law has never favored us, and we know our history with the police in this country.  There are so many of us running around and doing stupid things with guns or being around our peers who carry guns and frequent areas places that are prone to violence.  If any incident occurs (and it always does) whether or not a blackman was responsible, if apprehended, he’s guilty by directly, or by association. This happens so frequently, that by now, we should understand the game. Sadly though, our folks continue to get caught up in situations that earn them incaceration or worse, death penalty.
    My questions are

    1. Was Mr. Davis in anyway associated with the ‘real’ suspect?
    2. Was Mr. Davis carrying a gun at any point of that fateful day?
                                       
                                             or

    Was Mr. Davis simply at the wrong place at the wrong time? If this is the case, I pray that God deliver him from the throngs of death. If it is that he is not the actual suspect but sort of mixed up with the person/persons involved in this crime, then we need to seriously and religiously charge our young people to avoid potentially dangerous mix ups with the wrong crowd or the wrong places like night clubs, strip clubs, etc. Too many lafe altering things happen in these places, and as we already know, the law is starked against us already.

    • Drew

      Black men will continue to fall into dangerous legal situations as long as they keep breaking the freakin law… Stop making excuses and stop crying.  Your history with the police is that you commit crimes and they arrest you. End of discussion.

      • Usman

        Fool, and what is your history? You kill, rape, and destroy nations, and not pay the price isn’t it? When have you bastard ever taken responsibility for your crimes against humanity? Far from crying, your days are numbered White pig! Like it or not, you all will decline in size and dominance, and you will reap what you have sown on this earth. Now, go drink poison.

        • Mr. White

          Me being a white pig, doesn’t have to do a damn thing. When you people kill each other on a regular basis, your end will come by your own hands. Hell, you people are doing to yourselves what the Klan has been trying to do for years. Keep it up, the world will be a safer place.

          • PETTYB

            Mr. White, you are a white piggg! You make my stomach turn because you are down right ignorant! You make your kind look worst then what we already know yall are!..But don’t worry your days well be numberd!….

        • Destiny

          I am white, my family comes from the south in the days of slaves, yet NONE of my family owned slaves. The other half of my family came from the north, and fought for slaves freedom. I was never taught by any side of my family to hate any one no matter what their skin color. I was told to judge a person based on their actions and nothing else. I did not know what discrimination was until I was almost an adult.

          I have never “punished” any one because of their skin color, even though i have been for mine by many races. I have been mentally, verbally, and even sometimes physically attacked for my skin color and still to this day after going through all of that, I still will not persecute a person based on skin, faith, gender, or sexual preference. And I will raise my 4 children the same way, and hope they are strong enough to endure all that will come their way for that thought process.

          So please I beg that people stop blaming all white people of these evil crimes against you. I can promise I have never tried to do any harm to anyone based off of their skin, and if i have my way neither will my children.

          With that said I am fairly sure this was here to discuss the innocents or guilt of a man on death row. And if you truly believe this man is innocent do not disrespect him and his family with these petty arguments of race. And stick with proving points through facts.

      • Ben

        DREW FUCK YOU…. THAT IS NOT OUR HISTORY….. we have been abused tortured harassed degraded preyed upon abused discriminated…. all at that hands of law enforcement from every department that the united states has. YOU WILL NEVER NO WHAT ITS LIKE TO BE A BLACK MAN IN THIS FUCKING COUNTRY…… YOU IGNORANT FUCK

      • Ben

        DREW FUCK YOU…. THAT IS NOT OUR HISTORY….. we have been abused tortured harassed degraded preyed upon abused discriminated…. all at that hands of law enforcement from every department that the united states has. YOU WILL NEVER NO WHAT ITS LIKE TO BE A BLACK MAN IN THIS FUCKING COUNTRY…… YOU IGNORANT FUCK

  • Blacxkcobra

    Ok this is a long shot if today the board wants to go on with lethal inject I have a idea that might take it back the Supreme court just might work, send word to his lawyer and tell them that the state of GA does not have the Constitutional right to move forward with this inject because when the Constitution was sign African American were never a part of the paper and still not today,and the forefathers who sign this paper have since died and it was not ever resign to make all mankind equal in this country, and also a woman never was never written upon this paper, a woman duties are no longer in the kitchen and bedroom as most people think and say, but for this man if the witness change they stories the courts need to look at this thing more clearly before it cost taxpayers and this man his life, no gun was found no nothing no DNA so how can we judge this man, now let argument this before the high court before we try and kill a innocent man, and tell them BLACXKCOBRA said that cause my teacher taught me to say that which was in the civil rights movement,along with Dr. King
    Thank u

    BLACXKCOBRA//PRINCE OF THA UNITEX STATES

  • Blacxkcobra

    Ok this is a long shot if today the board wants to go on with lethal inject I have a idea that might take it back the Supreme court just might work, send word to his lawyer and tell them that the state of GA does not have the Constitutional right to move forward with this inject because when the Constitution was sign African American were never a part of the paper and still not today,and the forefathers who sign this paper have since died and it was not ever resign to make all mankind equal in this country, and also a woman never was never written upon this paper, a woman duties are no longer in the kitchen and bedroom as most people think and say, but for this man if the witness change they stories the courts need to look at this thing more clearly before it cost taxpayers and this man his life, no gun was found no nothing no DNA so how can we judge this man, now let argument this before the high court before we try and kill a innocent man, and tell them BLACXKCOBRA said that cause my teacher taught me to say that which was in the civil rights movement,along with Dr. King
    Thank u

    BLACXKCOBRA//PRINCE OF THA UNITEX STATES

    • Drew

      How freakin illiterate is your writing…

  • LeCalabro

    Jury nullification and recantations are not unusual in the African American community. Blacks sticking up for each other is not unusual. 95% of blacks voted for President Obama—and most of us believe that they did vote that way because he is black.

    Troy Davis is guilty of murdering that white police officer and Justice demands that the State carry out its court judgement.  Sad, burt true. 

    • SickOfIt

      I really don’t care what race you are but I am curious, why are you so sure he is guilty? I am a black man, I don’t know if he did it or not and personally don’t care. I am interested though in why people who don’t know any of the real facts have such strong opinions about the case but know nothing about it and even less about the law. Not saying that you don’t, for all I know you are a lawyer in the case.

  • Lydiaradden

    Read the story, a complicated one and seriously typical of individuals caught in the “line of fire” getting involved with the wrong people. Their is so much to this case that has not been forthcoming, by media, family or law enforcement. I don’t think this case is as cute and dry as individuals are trying to present. There are a lot of factors of concern here, starting with the incident leading up to the shooting and disappearance of those witnessing this altercation. When the officer was shoot, did  these three simply scatter, Davis claims he left before the shooting. So therefore he didn’t witness what occurred, sounds fishy. He may just be innocent, but knows what occurred and unfortunate for him he didn’t come forward before Coles had a chance to implicate him. Don’t put emphasis on racism, because it was his ‘black’ associates that implicated him in this in the first place. Police coercion, there is a lot more going on here than simply dragging racism into this picture. Certainly racism might be a factor, but look at the whole entire picture. Look at the players in this tragedy, the other suspects and so-called witnesses who all originally implicated Davis, and I don’t buy that police coercion explanation for the entire bunch. There are two sides here, which haven’t been addressed.

  • Xve777

    So 7 out of 9 witnesses recant their statements….two are now charged w/crimes….umm maybe it reflects the character of Davis but of his friends too.   No one can remember what they said 20 years ago…. There is a fact that Davis bragged to everyone of murdering the police officer…even to his own preacher…. It is time to put this dog down.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_X5Y5CDC2MEBI7VQ4DBWYXEGHSA Eric

      They should put you down for your convuluted white supremacist thought process.  Your mindset is why we have so many innocent black people on death row.  And you are asserting information that is not true. Witnesses do not equate to friends and Davis did not admit the murder to a pastor. 

      • wrickard

        Facts sure seem to say that this person is guilty with out any doubt let alone reasonable. He should of been put down after a couple of years. Our system is set up for the criminals and so many blindly follow with out knowing the facts. Glad He is finally done, makes me sick to see these in human cold blooded killers made out to be martyrs. The sad thing is there are thousand more just like Him and will kill with out any respect for a human life.

    • PETTYB

      Xve777, You ought to be a shame of yourself for being so damn crul!!!!…… Your name should be Xve666 cuse your the DEVIL!!!!!

    • Aaron

      How totally insensitive you are, quite possible you or one of your family members may need compassion and the decision to put your “dog” down.

  • http://twitter.com/axeplaya Axeplaya1

    my understanding is that all of those recantations, none of them were done in a court of law, is that true?  

  • http://twitter.com/axeplaya Axeplaya1

    also, it was said that he was convicted of another shooting that same day, and that hasn’t been challenged, and the bullets from that shooting match this crime exactly.  so if he did that shooting, he gave the gun to somebody else and they committed this crime?

  • Darryl

    Well the USA has 5% of the world’s population and 25% of the world’s prison population. Some other countries that have the death penalty are Saudi Arabia, Cuba, North Korea and China. European countries, Australia, Canada, Mexico and other civilized countries do not. Does this tell you something.

    • Mr. White

      Are you kidding me? Mexico a civilized country. Do you not read the paper? That man is GUILTY and his time has come. One less person to house and feed.

  • Cottonsack1

    we are fighting for our lives on two fronts cross seas and at home,why are we so eager to kill our own people,we are supose to be world leaders if we can’t get alone with our own people we sure can’t police the world,i believe in my heart troy davis case should be look at again.

  • Pittsburgher

    The case against Troy Davis is a travisty.  I just heard about it and I can’t believe it.  I would like to sign a petition against it but I wasn’t able to find the petition.

    • anonymous

      I did sign the petition against it and it is a sad shame that he was put to death without a new trial

  • blkgalusa

    Knowing how dangerous black young people are in today’s society, it would not surprise me at all if he did do it.  I think that not giving him clemency is their way of sending a message to these young thugs that enough is enough..you cannot shot and kill a peace officer and get away with it.  If this would be done in all states perhaps, just perhaps they would think twice.  Then again, these young gang members absolutely have no regard for human life.  I do not know all the facts in this case but it is more likely than not that he did do it.  We need to think a minute before we start jumping on the discrimination band wagon just because he is a black man.
     

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_TX25TESKN5D4OR3T4T6W5B2CQE Mr. Nonchalant

      And just how dangerous are young white people in todays society? You need to think a minute before you judge someone who may be innocent. Do you how IGNORANT you sound putting in your stupid comments, and you say you dont know all the fact s of thecase? i cant wait till we weed out all of the IGNORANT white people of this world.IGNOR

      • Mr. White

        You are an IDIOT! Dangerous white youth? Some, yes, but the young black youth kill each other on a daily basis. You people in the black community need to stop looking for excuses and do something to EDUCATE your youth. When they learn to act like normal people, speak like normal people then maybe society will listen when another black man is killed. Mr. Nonchalant, what can I say, if we weeded out all the IGNORANT Negros like yourself then there wouldn’t be any left.

        • mixed&proud

          Mr “white” if you truly are white since most of Americans are mixed in some shape or fashion,our youth are desperate need of our help period! Black,White,Mexican and every other race ! Yes young black men are killing each other daily but…young white men and women our killing themselves more! (suicides) and please do not forget the many school children around the world who have lost their lives to young “white” boys bringing their fathers guns to school and randomly picking off children and teachers of any race.Oh yea and what about the many “white” serial killers in America who have killed thousands of women children and in some cases men ,(even eating them)! It is not a competition on who’s race is the best or worst,I guess we could blam the Mexicans for all the cocaine tha”ts killing our young black men and women right? Absolutely not! This is about Americans supporting Americans didnt 911 teach you anything?With that being said Our legal system has made its ruling just like it did with Casey Anthony(white) and no matter how we feel about it its done!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

        • PETTYB

          Why don’t you just shut the hellll up white man!!!!!!!! We all know that you are a racist ass man! And on top of that you are a fuckin idiot! You know nothing about us you pig! So quit judging us by what you hear and go off what your ass know! Which can’t be much because all i hear is negativity comming from your ignorant ass! Every comment from you is racist you need to go to church! You need the LORD in your life bad!

        • Avery_cochran

           u know. i’m nobody to judge. i respect your opinion as a man, but i despise you as a human. first of all, who are you to say we are the most ignorant and we need to learn? if anything the white youth is diluted with ignorance. you mother fuckers bomb and shoot up schools and target different races for what the live for in a negative and hateful way. you want to be big and bad but you can’t even call me a NIGGER to my face. but when you’re with Tom and Becky and dumb ass Dan, you not afraid to speak your mind. let me catch yo ass, its gon be another story. But you see, i can go there with you, or i can take the scenic route. and educate simple minded people like yourself. i just hope that before you curse a child into this world that you have the proper knowledge to teach that ignorant white baby of yours.   -FuTuRe!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • PETTYB

      You shouldn’t speack on something that you don’t have all the facts on! Why is people so quick to judge and point their fingure at someone without even knowing the damn truth?!!!

  • notwhitenotblack

    It is over for Troy. After reading about this case, it certainly seems confusing in a few ways.  I want to believe he did not do it. The other gun incident, however, the one that tied the two incidents together via the ballistics, remains a big factor against.  I have not read anything that really addresses that part. I do agree that there seems to be reasonable doubt about this.

    There is no doubt though that the racist BS on this thread should stop. Nothing good can possibly come from it.  Those of you who want to point fingers might want to consider getting up off your butt and becoming part of the solution. Until then, you are part of the problem.

    • SickOfIt

      This might be the first intelligent post I read on this whole thread…GOD Bless You.

    • Aaron

      These comments especially those racist gentile comments edited prior to posting to eliminate the trailer trash and filth spued.

  • Aaron

    I’m at a loss as to why Mr. Davis didn’t name the killer if he was there when the incident took place to save his own life?

  • xavier michael 23

    me being who i am, have a black mother n white father, i think i am able to put my oppinion in this matter without bein called racist and supporting white supremacey, for one, troy davis has been on death row for 20 years for what killing a cop , thier is niggas out here killing people everyday, just becasue they can, adn all they get is 3 hot n a cot for 5-10, just because someone has a better job then you doesnt make it right to put that person to death, so what cops get killed all the time, it is a race thing, i mean foreal, look at that white girl, casey anthoney, bitch killed her own child and she get a one way ticket to fukin cancun mexico, why casue she is white, ohh so its okay ifa white bitch kills her baby, but a nigga cant kill a cop, i mean fuck when u grow up in the streets n grown to hate cops, what the fuck do you expect a nigga to do, but the man served 20 years, another 20 years he would have been dead anyway, why just not let him spend his time , and pass on sleepin in the night, but no the white man, has to say fuck tat we need his bed, no forreal our justice system s so fucked up that a ngga robs a liquor store and gets more time then a white man rapin a bitch, pure point blank no matter if he killed that cop or not, troy davis didnt deserve to die

  • xavier michael 23

    me being who i am, have a black mother n white father, i think i am able to put my oppinion in this matter without bein called racist and supporting white supremacey, for one, troy davis has been on death row for 20 years for what killing a cop , thier is niggas out here killing people everyday, just becasue they can, adn all they get is 3 hot n a cot for 5-10, just because someone has a better job then you doesnt make it right to put that person to death, so what cops get killed all the time, it is a race thing, i mean foreal, look at that white girl, casey anthoney, bitch killed her own child and she get a one way ticket to fukin cancun mexico, why casue she is white, ohh so its okay ifa white bitch kills her baby, but a nigga cant kill a cop, i mean fuck when u grow up in the streets n grown to hate cops, what the fuck do you expect a nigga to do, but the man served 20 years, another 20 years he would have been dead anyway, why just not let him spend his time , and pass on sleepin in the night, but no the white man, has to say fuck tat we need his bed, no forreal our justice system s so fucked up that a ngga robs a liquor store and gets more time then a white man rapin a bitch, pure point blank no matter if he killed that cop or not, troy davis didnt deserve to die

  • Heaton

    For those who took any time at all to study the details in the case of Troy Davis, the facts seem to vindicate the system that condemned him. His defense claimed there were only 9 witnesses when in fact there were 34 who witnessed the brutal murder that night. The defense claimed seven of those witnesses recanted when in fact only two offered recantations of any substance. When the defense was offered the opportunity to bring them into an appeals court to testify they refused to do so and one can only assume that the Davis team realized that their changed testimony wouldn’t hold up in court.

    Three of the thirty-four witnesses were Air Force personnel who were sitting in a bus that night. When asked if they would recant they replied that they would not! One never forgets, not even after 20 years when one man stands over another and shoots him in the face.

    The defense also claimed there was no physical evidence even though the shell casings picked up in the parking lot that night matched shell casings that Troy Davis had used in a previous shooting that very evening. Jurors obviously were not told of the bloody shorts found in Troy Davis’ laundry by investigators.

    After multiple appeals over a twenty year period, every court and every judge along the way declared the guilt of Troy Davis. When this information reached the highest court in the land they could find no reason to overturn what had been decided again and again by the lower courts.

    I was astonished to see protestors wearing signs that declared, “I am Troy Davis.” Troy Davis had been declared a cold blooded murderer. Why would anyone want to be Troy Davis?